Most countries celebrate their most successful authors.
My country is especially blessed with one treasured around the world — the brain responsible for the wizarding world of Harry Potter.
Yet our 21st-century Queen of Scots could face prison very soon.
Our “hate speech” ban came into force Monday, creating a new offense of “stirring up hatred” against protected categories — including based on transgender identity and sexual orientation.
Of course, nobody likes to be hated.
But the law is vague and far-reaching, without clear parameters around what the state decides could be “hateful” language.
Could it be illegal to state facts about women’s biological reality?
Could it be a crime to defend marriage between a man and a woman?
Depending on the context, nobody knows.
The legislation was proposed in 2020, and I responded with my first-ever comment piece.
I warned J.K. Rowling could face jail for tweeting her beliefs under the future law — one of the Western world’s most severe crackdowns on speech, making it dangerous even to discuss biological reality with your kids at the dinner table.
“Free” speech could suddenly cost seven years behind bars.
Humza Yousaf — then justice minister and author of the censorial bill — disagreed.
In an interview the following month, he stated emphatically that Rowling would not be punished for her public “gender critical” tweets.
The bill passed.
Police Scotland had to implore the government to delay enacting the law.
It faced an overwhelming rise in “hate” reports, with many from the “He said, she said” of the Twittersphere.
The forces needed time for “training, guidance and communications planning,” it said.
We waited. For three years.
That’s right — authorities had more than 1,000 days to address the real concerns raised when the bill went through Parliament.
Why was there so little clarity on which words or opinions met the threshold of “stirring up hate”?
Why is “transgender identity” a protected category but “female” isn’t?
Would using the “wrong” pronoun count as being “hateful”?
Would they really allow kids to report their parents for what they said in their own homes?
Yet here we are. The act came into force Monday — and it’s no April Fools’ joke.
We’re none the wiser as to how we can hold robust conversations about important social matters without risking a stretch in jail.
Police will investigate every hate crime reported, we’re told — the same month it announced it will no longer prosecute 24,000 minor offenses.
Scotland will surely be the first country where offending someone’s feelings could come at higher risk of punishment than stealing their possessions.
The state is coming after people who say things it doesn’t like.
And that early reassurance from Humza Yousaf that Rowling would not be punished for her gender-critical beliefs?
Highly questionable.
Twitter is awash with activists declaring themselves ready to report her belief in biological reality to the authorities.
The great Scottish witch hunt is a tale as old as time.
It was historically easier to silence problematic women if they were called “witches.”
Today, they’re “hate monsters” who need to be locked up if they hold beliefs not mob-approved.
Indeed, it’s clear Yousaf hadn’t looked at the consequences of similar hate-speech laws across the world before making his claim.
In Mexico, two politicians from differing parties have been convicted of “gender based political violence” and placed on an offenders’ register, simply for upholding their beliefs about gender and pronouns on Twitter.
There’s nothing to stop our hate-crime law from doing the same thing.
It might be April 1, but J.K. Rowling doesn’t suffer fools gladly.
She’s challenged Police Scotland to come and arrest her for essentially declaring a woman is an adult human female and calling out those who pretend otherwise.
She could be at risk — yet she’s shown stamina in upholding her convictions.
Will citizens with less money or influence be able to withstand the pressure?
Or will they stay quiet for fear of trouble?
It’s a dark day for the land once famous for freedom, culture, comedy and the great Scottish enlightenment.
Time will tell how quickly we descend into a “monster hunt.”
Lois McLatchie Miller is a Scottish free-speech advocate with Alliance Defending Freedom UK.
News
Taylor Swift Fan Defends Booking 191 Hotel Rooms Ahead of New Orleans Tour Stop, Shares Real Plans for Them (Exclusive)
“I fought really, really, really hard for every single room and every single person and just so it’s entirely clear, I’ve done this all at cost,” Rebecca Fox says Taylor Swift. Photo: Kevin Winter/Getty Images for TAS Rights Management The second North…
HOT NEW!Drake and Chris Brown Reportedly Face Another Copyright Infringement Lawsuit Over 2019 Hit ‘No Guidance’
After a separate lawsuit was dropped two years ago, a new complaint alleges the song infringes on the copyright of the 2016 song “I Got It” by Tykeiya. Drake and Chris Brown in the ‘No Guidance’ video YouTube Drake could…
Ed Sheeran Dresses Up as AI-Generated Meme of Himself Wearing Monkey Costume for Halloween
“Haters will say it’s AI,” joked the Grammy winner on social media Ed Sheeran. Photo: Ed Sheeran/Instagram There are layers to the story behind Ed Sheeran’s 2024 Halloween costume. The 33-year-old Grammy winner celebrated the annual spooky holiday on Oct. 31 by dressing…
Ed Sheeran recreates his viral AI meme: ‘Haters will say it’s AI’
The singer sparked plenty of laughs with a humorous spin on his viral meme Ed Sheeran grabbed his fans’ attention with a simple yet hilarious twist on his AI-generated trending photo. The Shape of You singer marked his spooky holiday on…
John Tavares has chillingly cruel advice for the 22-year-old Toronto Maple Leafs forward
John Tavares has brutally honest advice for 22-year-old Toronto Maple Leafs forward (image credit: IMAGN) John Tavares sees a path where Matthew Knies will have a long and productive career. Tavares knows he has the talent, but also sees his…
“Should be given a death sentence”: NHL fans outraged by Matt Stienburg’s two-game suspension for brutal attack on Tampa Bay’s Erik Cernak
“Should have been given death sentence”: NHL fans react to Matt Stienburg’s two-game suspension for charging Tampa Bay’s Erik Cernak – Source: Imagn On Thursday, NHL’s Department of Player Safety suspended Colorado Avalanche forward Matt Stienburg for two games for his…
End of content
No more pages to load