JK Rowling has criticised Anneliese Dodds’ past comments on the definition of a woman (PA Wire)
JK Rowling has criticised the new women and equalities minister over previous remarks she has made on gender.
The Harry Potter author called past comments made by Anneliese Dodds on gender “nonsensical” as the Labour MP’s new appointment was announced, after Ms Rowling previously accused Labour of having “abandoned” her and others campaigning for women’s rights.
The novelist has frequently argued online that trans women are not women and criticised Scottish Government proposals to introduce self-identification for transgender people.
Shortly after Monday’s announcement, Ms Rowling tweeted part of a transcript from an interview Ms Dodds had taken part in for BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour in 2022.
According to the posted transcript, when asked for Labour’s definition of a woman, Ms Dodds said there are “different definitions legally around what a woman actually is” and, when pressed again, said: “I think it does depend what the context is.”
Ms Rowling tweeted: “And if you happen to be wondering how I have the transcript of that Woman’s Hour to hand, it was sent to me by Dodds’ office after I publicly criticised her prevarication on the programme. They seemed to think I’d find her comments less nonsensical if I saw them in print.”
Anneliese Dodds has been appointed a minister of state – Minister for Women and Equalities – in the Department for Education (REUTERS)
Last October, speaking at Labour’s National Annual Women’s Conference, Ms Dodds said a Labour win in the election would see her “become the UK’s first ever Secretary of State for Women and Equalities, with a seat at the top table, dedicated to advocating for women in all their diversity in every Cabinet conversation”.
The Government is facing criticism from a coalition of campaigning organisations for not following through on that dedicated position, accused of offering a “diluted alternative” and “bolt-on ministerial briefs”.
Ms Dodds has been appointed a minister of state – Minister for Women and Equalities – in the Department for Education, serving under Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson who was named also Minister for Women and Equalities.
However, the prime minister’s spokesperson said Ms Dodds will be the lead minister, with Ms Phillipson having also been named a minister for “constitutional purposes” as she is a Secretary of State.
The spokesperson said: “Anneliese Dodds will be the Minister for Women and Equalities and will be, as I understand it, attending Cabinet but for sort of constitutional purposes you also need someone who’s a full Cabinet member having the brief as part of their role, but for all intents and purposes, Anneliese Dodds will be the lead minister.”
Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson previously warned against ‘picking fights, seeking headlines’ on issues around gender (PA Wire)
Ms Dodds, in her time as shadow women and equalities secretary, affirmed Labour’s commitment to “trans people and women” and criticised the demonisation of vulnerable people.
Last year she said Labour is “committed to modernising the Gender Recognition Act”.
In an article for The Guardian, she added: “Changing gender is not a decision anyone makes lightly. The process is intrusive, outdated and humiliating. So we will modernise, simplify and reform the gender recognition law to a new process. We will remove invasive bureaucracy and simplify the process.”
Meanwhile, Ms Phillipson has previously warned against “picking fights, seeking headlines” on issues around gender.
During the election campaign, Ms Phillipson said she wanted to take the heat out of the row over transgender guidance for schools.
“Let’s stop this being a political football,” she told the BBC. “This is our children’s lives, their wellbeing, it’s too important to make this a culture wars issue on the front pages of newspapers.”
Draft guidance, published before the election was called, stated that England’s schools should not teach about the concept of gender identity.
Asked if she would ditch the proposed ban, Ms Phillipson said trans people’s “existence should be recognised” before saying discussion on the issue “drifts sometimes into a slightly bizarre conversation”.
She has also previously said “statutory guidance” on single-sex spaces would be set out by a Labour government.
Last month, she said: “I do believe in the importance of single-sex provision, but I also believe that trans people have the right to appropriate care as well. I don’t think it is about one or the other.”
The Conservative government had, before the election was called, announced plans to overhaul the NHS Constitution to “ensure that biological sex is respected”, referring to proposals to ensure hospital patients in England have the right to request to be treated on single-sex wards, with transgender people placed in rooms on their own.
Separately, Agenda Alliance, a coalition of organisations representing women and girls with unmet needs, said it was “an early missed opportunity” not to put in place a dedicated Secretary of State for Women and Girls.
Indy Cross, chief executive of the alliance, said: “We’ve been really clear that only a dedicated Cabinet post will have the political clout to bring about change.
“The letter we at Agenda Alliance sent to our now Prime Minister, with over 60 signatures from key specialist support organisations, showed the urgent need for a champion at the top table to fight the corner of women and girls, especially those at the sharpest edge of adversity. Not some diluted alternative.
“Bolt-on ministerial briefs will not cut it. We know women and girls deserve better. A fully-fledged, dedicated secretary of state is what we’ll continue to argue for. We look forward to working with the new government to achieve this.”
News
Emma Watson stuns fans with ‘levitating’ dress
Emma Watson fans have been left confused by her latest fashion statement. The actor, 33, who is best known for starring as Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter film adaptations, shared a photo to Instagram on Monday (19 June), in which she posed…
JK Rowling’s King Lear-like dispute with her ‘children’ is tragic to behold
Sean O’Grady wonders what we might learn from the dramatic rift between the Harry Potter author and the child stars of her movie franchise who turned against her because of her trans views JK Rowling photographed with Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson…
JK Rowling has faced ridicule for her gender-critical views, but that hasn’t hindered her success.
The Edinburgh-based Harry Potter author wrote The Ink Black Heart under her Robert Galbraith pseudonym and social media users reckon there is an irony in her still being successful at the same time a business that mocked her goes into…
JK Rowling calls out ‘trans activist outrage’ as she proclaims ‘women’s rights are human rights’
The Harry Potter author hit out at her critics who have been angered by her views that biological men should not share prisons with vulnerable female inmates JK Rowling has accused her critics of being unrighteous as she hit out…
The famous director of the classic film The Bling Ring shares unforgettable memories of Emma Watson, Taissa Farmiga with a nostalgic Instagram post.
The director also gave Hilton a shout-out for “graciously opening her home” to the cast and crew. It’s been 10 years since Emma Watson and Taissa Farmiga went on a fame-obsessed, internet-enabled crime spree in The Bling Ring, and director Sofia Coppola is marking the anniversary with…
Leaked close-up photos of Diddy’s private party, shuddering at the sick details, Katy Perry was called out
A photo from inside Diddy’s lavish party was shared publicly and is causing a storm of public opinion. That offensive scene made the public around the world shudder. Diddy’s scandal continues to be the focus of the American entertainment industry…
End of content
No more pages to load