Anthony Stolarz may actually become the Maple Leafs starting goalie in 2024-25, according to Sam Reinhart

Maple Leafs goaltender Anthony Stolarz set to take the reigns as number 1 goalie in Toronto?

When Stolarz struck a deal with the Maple Leafs at the start of free agency, the common perception of the deal was that he’d be coming to Toronto as sophomore goaltender Joseph Woll’s number two. However, Panthers star forward Sam Reinhart revealed this week that it’s just as reasonable to think that Stolarz can come in and not only press Woll for starts, but actually become the Leafs’ number one goaltender.

Fresh off of their Stanley Cup win back in June, the Panthers lost some key players on July 1st, including two to the Maple Leafs in Stolarz and Oliver Ekman-Larsson. While the jury is still out on what OEL will be able to accomplish in Toronto, just about everyone who knows Anthony Stolarz has come forward to express how excited they are for him and just how phenomenal of a goaltender he actually is — Reinhart among them.
New Florida Panthers Goalie Anthony Stolarz: Winning Is The Thing

“[Stolarz] has a good chance to be that goalie for that organization that they’ve needed,” said Reinhart this week, insinuating that he could be the starter this season.

Reinhart also spoke of Stolarz’s contributions to the Panthers on their Cup run and his high quality character, which should fit in very well in a tight-knit Leafs locker room. In addition, he delivered a little jab towards his friend and former goaltender.

“He was unbelievable. One, his personality off the ice is top-notch. It’s something that anyone would want in their room So I’m excited to see (that happen) for him as a person. Obviously, I hope he doesn’t do too well, against us at least. But I wish nothing but the best for him and that opportunity. It’s something that’s deserved through a lot of hard work.”

Anthony Stolarz discusses life as backup goalie during Stanley Cup Final run - The Hockey News Florida Panthers News, Analysis and More
Whether Stolarz can maintain his tremendous play across a larger number of games in Toronto remains to be seen, but if he can produce numbers comparable to the ones he posted last season, a 16-7-2 record with a .925 SV% and a 2.03 GAA, then perhaps we will see Stolarz getting the lion’s share of the starts in Toronto in 2024-25.