The Controversy Between Vic Sotto, Joey de Leon, and Atasha Muhlach: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes

In early July 2025, the Philippine entertainment industry was shaken by news that veteran actor Aga Muhlach had filed a formal lawsuit against two of the country’s most iconic TV personalities—Vic Sotto and Joey de Leon. The suit accused the pair of humiliating and degrading his daughter, Atasha Muhlach, during her guest appearance on the noontime television show Eat Bulaga! (also known as E.A.T. on TV5).

The incident quickly became a trending topic on social media and raised questions about what really transpired on set—and whether lines were crossed in the name of comedy.

The Allegations: “Crossing the Line” on Live TV

According to the lawsuit, Vic Sotto and Joey de Leon allegedly made inappropriate and suggestive remarks toward Atasha during her brief stint as a guest co-host on Eat Bulaga! The statements, described by Aga Muhlach as “sexually suggestive” and “disrespectful,” were broadcast live and soon went viral through video snippets circulating online.

Aga publicly stated that his daughter felt “deeply humiliated” and that the remarks went far beyond light-hearted banter. He emphasized that while humor is a staple of noontime TV, it should never come at the expense of someone’s dignity—especially a young woman like Atasha who was new to live television and still finding her footing in the entertainment world.

Charlene Gonzalez Breaks Her Silence

Following the public backlash and the filing of the lawsuit, Charlene Gonzalez, Atasha’s mother, issued a calm and measured statement to clarify what had happened. She denied any personal conflict between Atasha and the two senior hosts and explained that Atasha’s involvement with the show was always meant to be short-term due to her other contractual obligations.

Charlene confirmed that Atasha had signed on for a brief appearance while she was preparing for her role in the upcoming Filipino adaptation of Bad Genius, produced by Viva Films. She thanked Vic and Joey for treating her daughter “with professionalism and respect” during her time on the show. According to Charlene, there was no falling-out behind the scenes—only a mutual understanding that Atasha had other priorities.

Despite her statement, many netizens remained divided. Some criticized Vic and Joey for their brand of humor, which some viewed as outdated or inappropriate, especially in the modern era of social awareness. Others defended the veteran comedians, claiming that the remarks were taken out of context and that Eat Bulaga! has always relied on “edgy” banter as part of its comedic style.

From Rumors to Reality: Untangling the Narrative

The controversy was further complicated by previous false rumors about Atasha’s personal life. In late 2024, fake news circulated on social media alleging that she was pregnant with Vico Sotto’s child—a claim that was quickly debunked. Atasha herself denied the rumors and clarified that she had never even met Vico in person.

These rumors likely contributed to the heightened sensitivity around her presence on Eat Bulaga! and the media frenzy that followed. Some fans speculated that the show’s jokes were inspired by the previous online gossip, thus making them even more inappropriate in the eyes of critics.

Aga Muhlach’s Legal Move: A Father’s Duty

While Charlene attempted to defuse tensions, Aga Muhlach took a more serious route. As a father, he felt it was his duty to take legal action and stand up for his daughter’s dignity. His lawsuit, filed in Quezon City, accuses Vic and Joey of workplace harassment, public defamation, and emotional distress inflicted on Atasha.

Though the specifics of the case are still under review, the move has sparked a broader discussion about the treatment of women on Philippine television, particularly young celebrities who are often subjected to inappropriate remarks under the guise of “comedy.”

Public Reaction: Split Between Support and Skepticism

Social media exploded with opinions on both sides. Hashtags like #RespectAtasha and #StandWithAga trended for days, with many praising Aga for standing up against inappropriate behavior. Others, however, criticized the lawsuit as an overreaction and accused the Muhlach family of being “too sensitive.”

Still, a significant portion of the public acknowledged that Philippine TV—especially noontime shows—needs to adapt its humor to modern standards. What was once seen as “harmless fun” is now being re-examined through the lens of respect, professionalism, and gender sensitivity.

Conclusion: A Turning Point for Philippine Entertainment?

As of now, there has been no formal apology issued by either Vic Sotto or Joey de Leon. Sources close to the show claim the two hosts were “caught off guard” by the lawsuit and are considering their legal options. Meanwhile, Atasha continues to focus on her upcoming film and has refrained from making public statements since the controversy erupted.

This incident may well become a watershed moment in Philippine showbiz, prompting a reevaluation of what constitutes acceptable humor—especially when it involves younger, less experienced artists. Whether the lawsuit proceeds or is settled privately, it has already sparked a necessary conversation about boundaries, respect, and the evolving standards of public entertainment.