
Publishing staff are upset at J.K. Rowling’s anti-trans tirade. (Getty)
A woman who called LBC host James O’Brien to defend J.K. Rowling had her argument that biology defines womanhood pulled apart live on air.
“Women have been very kind we are we are saying trans women are women – okay, that’s fine – but we have to draw the line and biology is the line,” the caller said.
“I’m so glad J.K. Rowling has helped us draw that line, because we’re oppressed because of our biology. Women around the world are oppressed, because they are biologically women.”
The woman was referring to J.K. Rowling’s recent tweet in support of a woman who sought to have her “gender-critical views” protected under the UK Equalities Act.
After a judge ruled that Maya Forstater’s anti-trans views were “absolutist,” Rowling tweeted: “Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who’ll have you. Live your best life in peace and security. But force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?”
LBC caller says trans women ‘aren’t raped like women are.’

As the caller underlined the idea of a “biological woman”, O’Brien asked what differences she was referring to.
“Trans women don’t suffer from female genital mutilations, that is suffered by females,” she replied.
“Trans women aren’t raped like women are, trans women aren’t murdered twice a week by their partners.”
On international Trans Day of Remembrance, it was reported that 331 trans people had been murdered in the year between October 1, 2018 and September 20, 2019.
The caller continued to make the argument that trans women could not be women because they don’t produce eggs, which quickly fell apart under inspection.
“Do you cease to be woman if you have no ovaries or you don’t menstruate?” O’Brien asked.
The caller argued that the distinction is whether “your body was built to be able to produce” eggs, which O’Brien pointed out “sounds a little bit complicated.”
I think the argument would be, well, the dice did roll very differently for me, and I can’t do that, but I am a woman.
“So how do we define biological womenhood?” he asked, before summarising the argument.
“It means you were built in a way that allows you to produce eggs and give birth except hundreds of thousands of women can’t. But they’re still women, because maybe if the dice rolled differently they could have done.”
With no trans woman in the room, he succinctly laid out what he thought would be the trans point of view.
“I think the argument would be, well, the dice did roll very differently for me, and I can’t do that, but I am a woman,” he said.
Before hanging up, he added: “It’s not helpful when you laugh at people who are trying to understand things that they find really complicated, especially if your explanations are nowhere near as clear as you think they are.”
J.K. Rowling’s tweet has provoked a fierce debate on Twitter, with a number of celebrities coming out against the Harry Potter author.
One woman who tried to make a similar argument about biology was put in her place beautifully by an evolutionary biologist who is intersex.
News
Palestine Action ‘terror’ group behind RAF Brize Norton raid ‘plots attacks on three more air bases and drone factory’
Keep scrolling for a map highlighting potential targets THE Palestine Action group behind the RAF Brize Norton raid is reportedly plotting attacks on three more air bases and a drone factory. The organisation is believed to be planning hits on…
Zion Williamson Finally Speaks Out on Shocking Allegations, Reveals Bold Response Plan
Zion Williamson Breaks Silence Over Explosive Allegations, Calls Lawsuit ‘Defamatory and Financially Motivated’ In a stunning development that has rocked the NBA world, New Orleans Pelicans star Zion Williamson is at the center of a legal firestorm following explosive allegations…
HOT NEWS ALERT: What was in that bag? Stefon Diggs hands off a suspicious package during a wild yacht party, and social media detectives are on the case. Theories are flying—and some are downright scandalous. This moment could be more than just a party clip!
“What Was in the Pink Bag? Stefon Diggs Sparks NFL Controversy After Yacht Party with Cardi B Goes Viral” Stefon Diggs is living large—maybe too large. The New England Patriots wide receiver has never been shy about enjoying the finer…
BREAKING: Shannon Sharpe just made a career-shaking announcement while staring down a $50 million lawsuit. Fans are stunned—was it a retirement, a power move, or something darker? The timing is no coincidence, and now the internet is split: is this damage control or defiance?
Shannon Sharpe Postpones Nightcap Tour Amid $50 Million ***ual ****ult Lawsuit: What It Means for His Media Empire and Career In a stunning turn of events that has sent shockwaves through the sports and entertainment world, NFL Hall of Famer…
CAUGHT RED-HANDED: A cameraman was exposed during a live women’s tennis match for zooming in from an inappropriate angle—and the moment the umpire called him out? The entire stadium gasped. Social media is in flames. Fans are demanding answers. Who let this happen… and how long has it gone on?
“BACK OFF!” Tennis Star Danielle Collins Confronts Cameraman in Fiery Courtside Clash During Strasbourg Match—Fans Divided Over How Close Is Too Close It wasn’t a racquet smash or an umpire outburst that stirred the biggest conversation at the Internationaux de…
SHOCKING RISE: From Chicago streets to the Vatican throne? Robert Prevost’s hidden past and fast climb through the church ranks will leave you stunned.
Chicago Native Becomes First American Pope, Ushering in a New Era for the Catholic Church Vatican City / Chicago – May 9, 2025 White smoke billowed from the Sistine Chapel this morning, signaling a monumental decision that would reverberate around…
End of content
No more pages to load
